Types of Eyeliner Explained: Which One Is Right for Your Look?

Introduction

Eyeliner is a go-to makeup essential that can instantly enhance your look. Whether you're keeping things soft and subtle or going all out with a dramatic wing, the right eyeliner makes all the difference. With so many options like pencil, liquid, and gel, choosing the right eyeliner can feel a bit confusing.

That’s where this guide comes in. We’ll break down the different types of eyeliner, what each one is best for, and how to use them like a pro. By the end, you’ll know exactly which eyeliner suits your style and how to apply it to get the look you want.

Different Types of Eyeliner

Eyeliner comes in all shapes, textures, and formulas. Every type of eyeliner has its own advantages and best ways to use it. Here's a breakdown of the most popular choices on the market:

Waterproof Eyeliner

If you want your eyeliner to stay sharp and smudge-free from morning to night, waterproof eyeliner is a game changer. It’s designed to handle everything—sweat, tears, rain, and even long, busy days—without fading or smearing. Whether you're going to a summer wedding, hitting the gym, or just have oily eyelids, this type of liner keeps your eye makeup looking fresh and flawless.

Why You’ll Love It:

• Long-Lasting Wear: Once it sets, it stays put for hours—even through heat, humidity, or emotional moments.

• Smudge-Resistant: Ideal for anyone who struggles with their liner smearing or fading throughout the day.

• Great for Dramatic Looks: If you love sharp wings or bold lines, waterproof formulas hold their shape perfectly.

Things to Keep in Mind:

• Tougher to Remove: Because it’s built to last, it won’t wash off with just water.

• Pro Tip: Use an oil-based or waterproof makeup remover to gently take it off without tugging on your skin.

• May Feel a Bit Drier: Some formulas can feel less creamy than regular eyeliner, so apply in short strokes for better control.

Best For:

Active days, special occasions, hot climates, or anyone who needs reliable, all-day eyeliner.

Liquid Eyeliner

If you love clean, bold lines and dramatic eye looks, liquid eyeliner is the tool for you. It’s perfect for creating sharp wings, cat eyes, or graphic designs that really stand out. The color is rich and intense, making your eyes pop with just one swipe.

Why You’ll Love It:

• Super Precise: Great for fine lines, wings, or any detailed work.

• Bold Color: Gives a deep, defined look that really stands out.

• Perfect for Drama: Ideal for when you want a strong, statement eye.

Things to Keep in Mind:

• Takes Practice: A steady hand helps—mistakes are more noticeable with liquid liners.

• Let It Dry: It can smudge if you blink before it sets, so give it a few seconds to dry.

• Helpful Tip: Choose a formula that dries quickly and lasts all day to avoid smudges and touch-ups.

Best For:

Winged liner lovers, special occasions, or anyone who enjoys a clean, professional makeup look. With a bit of practice, liquid eyeliner can become your go-to for crisp, eye-catching styles.

Felt-Tip Eyeliner

If you like the bold look of liquid eyeliner but want something easier to handle, felt-tip eyeliner might be your perfect match. It comes in a pen-style design that gives you more control, making it a great pick for beginners or anyone who struggles with a traditional brush.

Why You’ll Love It:

• Beginner-Friendly: The pen-style tip makes it easier to draw steady, clean lines.

• Precision Made Simple: Ideal for sharp wings or detailed designs without the mess.

• Liquid Look, Less Effort: Offers the bold color of a liquid liner but feels more like using a marker.

Things to Keep in Mind:

• Can Dry Out Quickly: Make sure to keep the cap tightly closed when not in use.

• Not Great for Smudging: If you like soft or blended lines, this might not be the best choice.

Best For:

Anyone who wants a precise, liquid-style liner but with easier handling. It’s especially handy for daily use or when you’re short on time but still want a polished look.

Gel Eyeliner

Gel eyeliner is a favorite for anyone who loves both precision and creativity. It usually comes in a small pot and is applied with a thin or angled brush. The texture is smooth and creamy, which makes it easy to control whether you're going for a sharp wing or a smudged, smoky look.

Why You’ll Love It:

• Rich Color That Lasts: Gel liners are super pigmented and stay put all day.

• Versatile Application: You can go for clean lines or blend it out for softer styles.

• Great for Creative Looks: Perfect for more detailed or dramatic eye makeup.

Things to Keep in Mind:

• You’ll Need a Brush: It doesn’t come with an applicator, so it’s an extra tool to carry.

• Can Dry Out Over Time: Make sure to close the lid tightly to keep it from drying.

Best For:

Anyone who enjoys experimenting with their eye makeup or wants a liner that can do both sharp and smudgy styles. It’s a go-to for makeup artists—and for good reason.

Cream Eyeliner

Cream eyeliner is a great pick if you prefer softer, more natural-looking eye makeup. It has a smooth, blendable texture that’s easier on the skin and ideal for creating gentle, diffused lines. Think of it as a more relaxed version of gel or liquid liner.

Why You’ll Love It:

• Super Blendable: Great for smoky eyes or soft, smudged looks.

• Gentle on the Eyes: Feels light and comfortable—perfect if you have sensitive skin.

• Fun Shade Options: Often comes in unique colors you won’t find in standard liners.

Things to Keep in Mind:

• Not for Sharp Lines: It’s better for soft styles than crisp, defined edges.

• Can Smudge: Use a setting spray or a bit of powder to help it stay in place longer.

Best For:

Creative makeup lovers who enjoy playing with texture and color. If you’re into trying new trends or love a blended eye look, cream eyeliner is a great option to have in your kit.

Pencil Eyeliner

Pencil eyeliner is a classic—and for good reason. It’s simple, easy to use, and great for everyday looks. Whether you’re just starting with makeup or need something quick for your morning routine, pencil liner is a go-to.

Why You’ll Love It:

• Beginner-Friendly: Super easy to apply, even if you're new to eyeliner.

• Versatile Style: Works well for soft, natural lines or smudged-out looks.

• Tons of Color Options: From classic black to bold blues and earthy browns, there’s a shade for every mood.

Things to Keep in Mind:

• Needs Sharpening: Regular use can dull the tip, so you’ll need to keep a sharpener handy.

• May Smudge: It doesn’t always stay put as long as waterproof or gel liners—especially on oily lids.

Pro Tip:

For a softer, smokier look, gently blend the line with a brush or your fingertip. And if you need more staying power, try a waterproof pencil—it gives you all the ease of a pencil with longer wear.

Conclusion

Finding the right eyeliner really comes down to what suits your style, eye shape, and comfort level. Whether you're mastering the art of removing waterproof eyeliner, blending out a smokey eye with gel, or testing a few from your list of favorite waterproof picks—there’s no one-size-fits-all answer.

Don’t hesitate to try out different types. Some days call for a sharp liquid wing, and other days you might just want a soft pencil line. Eyeliner is a great way to show off your personal style and get creative with your makeup.